My Story Tale is a real company, rated 4.9 from 7,019 Trustpilot reviews on 11 November 2026, and 89 of those reviews (1.3%) give 1 to 3 stars. The story is the commonest complaint: 20 of the 89, and 7 of the 17 from Australia, say it was generic, badly written or had the wrong people in it.
What My Story Tale’s buyers complain about
We read all 89 reviews of 1 to 3 stars, posted from 29 July 2025 to 9 November 2026, and sorted them by theme, some under more than one. Of the 89, 31 give one star (0.4% of all its reviews); My Story Tale replied to all 89.
The story: generic, badly written, or the wrong people in it
20 of 89Australian 7 of 17
Print, paper or damage
19 of 89Australian 2 of 17
Late, lost or misdelivered
15 of 89Australian 2 of 17
Order made or sent wrong: wrong book or cover, misspelt name, typed words not used
14 of 89Australian 3 of 17
Customer service slow or hard to reach
13 of 89Australian 0 of 17
Character didn’t look like the child
12 of 89Australian 0 of 17
Price or value
8 of 89Australian 2 of 17
Couldn’t preview the whole book
6 of 89Australian 1 of 17
Not about the product
5 of 89Australian 2 of 17
Seventeen is a small sample, so read the Australian counts as a pointer. Australians wrote:
- “Other than using the names I provided, there was nothing personalized in this story.” (2 stars, 10 September 2026)
- “The story wording is much too advanced for the target recipients.” (2 stars, 29 October 2026)
- “Not written well, doesn’t even rhyme.” (2 stars, 10 May 2026)
- “Throughout the book, the dad is featured prominently on all the pages, while the mum is completely absent.” (2 stars, 10 June 2026, of a big-sister book; My Story Tale found no order under the name)
- “Grandparents are no longer little old people, nor are activities gender specific” (3 stars, 2 April 2026)
- “Love the personalisation of the books. Arrived pretty quick. Only downside is the story could be better.” (4 stars, 14 October 2026)
Of its 7,019 reviews, 6,713 give five stars and 217 four. By our keyword count of the 250 most recent 4 and 5 star reviews, 40% praise the delivery, most of them its speed (24 of the 40 from Australia and New Zealand), 34% the look of the book and 27% its quality, and 52 mention a grandchild. An Australian wrote on 8 November 2026: “I’ve ordered 7 books so far for my grandchildren.” (5 stars)
The delivery
40%
The look of the book
34%
The quality
27%
A grandchild
52 of 250
Is My Story Tale legit?
Its contact-information page names the company: Personalized Story Group, Inc., 39 Everett Drive, West Windsor Township, New Jersey, which also runs Story Bug and Hooray Heroes. Its Australian company, Personalised Story Group Pty Ltd, is registered in NSW 2370, with an ABN (79 689 778 489) active since 6 August 2025 and the trading names My Story Tale, Story Bug and Wall Art Prints. The web address dates from July 2024 and its first book from December 2024, and the company says it took 100,000 orders in its first eight months.
Its reviews come from real buyers, almost all invited by the company after a purchase, which Trustpilot allows and which tends to gather happy buyers: 246 of the 250 most recent 4 and 5 star reviews came through Trustpilot’s invitation link. No review repeats another’s text, one-review accounts are as common among unhappy reviewers as happy ones, and low stars arrive in every month since July 2025.
It has no listing on ProductReview.com.au or the BBB, we found no Google Business Profile, and Reddit holds no first-hand report from a My Story Tale buyer.
What you get for your money
My Story Tale charges A$44.97 delivered for a 24-page hardcover and A$34.98 for a softcover; a Paperlake hardcover is A$99 delivered (checked 11 November 2026).
| Paperlake | My Story Tale | |
|---|---|---|
| Price, one book delivered | A$99 hardcover, A$119 Keepsake (adds a 6-photo album and an online copy) | A$34.98 softcover, A$44.97 hardcover: A$24.99 or A$34.98 plus A$9.99 post |
| The story | Written for this child from what you tell us | One of 76 fixed stories, with the name, a dedication and words you can edit |
| The pictures | Painted from the photos you send | A character built from options such as hair and skin tone; no photo |
| Who can be in it | The child and two more people included, up to six, pets too | Depends on the title |
| The book | 20 cm square hardcover, 32 pages, 14 story spreads | 23 × 23 cm, 24 pages, softcover or hardcover |
| See it before you pay | The whole story, the cover and the first two pages | “Preview Full Book” (its claim) |
| Made and delivered | Up to 3 business days to make, up to 10 in the post; arrival date shown before you pay | “within 3 business days from our Melbourne facility” (its claim); no time in the post stated |
| Order by for Christmas | Friday 4 December | No date published for Australia |
| If it’s not right | A reprint if you’re not happy | Its T&C: it aims to fix and replace faulty books reported within 90 days; unused change-of-mind returns posted to New Jersey at your cost |
How personal is a My Story Tale book?
The name, the character’s look, a dedication and some words are yours; the story is one of 76 fixed titles. Its FAQ: “Beyond just a name, you can often customize other details like their appearance, friends, or even their favorite things”. The titles cover babies, toddlers, Christmas (one set in “an Aussie-style festive season”), Easter, Halloween, grandparents, mums, dads, twins and new brothers and sisters. None is about a pet.
Who else fits depends on the title. A US buyer wrote “I was only able to add Mom” (3 stars, 19 February 2026), and another found the two extra names “were only included in the dedication of the book and not the main story” (2 stars, 11 February 2026).
My Story Tale asks for no photo. 12 of the 89 low-star reviews (13%) say the character didn’t look like the child: wrong hair or eye colour, a girl drawn as a boy, no hair option for Black hair. None came from Australia, though an Australian 4-star buyer found the cover child “looks like a boy as it has short hair” (27 October 2026). A US great-grandmother: “we did not get the option to select the picture of my great granddaughter. So the caricature did not really resemble her” (3 stars, 12 December 2025).
A Paperlake book starts from the family: “You tell us about the child: who they are, the people and pets around them, a real day you want kept. We write their story, and the pictures are painted from the photos you send.” The child and two more people are included and up to six fit, pets too: brothers, sisters, grandparents, the dog. You read the whole story and see the cover and the first two pages before you pay, and you can change any line; if the cover isn’t them, ask for another.
My Story Tale or a book written and painted for your child?
Choose My Story Tale if…
From A$34.98 delivered
One of its 76 titles fits them
Shipped within 3 business days, it says
No photo to upload
Choose Paperlake if…
A story written for this child
Their people and pets, painted from your photos
The whole story read before you pay
A reprint if it isn’t right
“I won’t lie, it brought a tear to my eye when I had it done, my grand daughter will love it.”
Is My Story Tale worth it?
That turns on the story, the thing its Australian buyers complain about most. Before you pay, read every page of the preview, and check that everyone you named is in the story itself and that the name is spelt right. A Paperlake book is written for the child from what you tell us, their people and pets are painted from your photos, and you read the whole story and can change any line before you pay. Order by Friday 4 December for Christmas.
Sources
- My Story Tale’s Australian site (mystorytale.com/en-au): home page and FAQ, product pages, All Books collection, Shipping Information page, Contact page (FAQ), refund policy, T&C page, terms of service and contact-information page. The company and its address, prices, post, foil, cart extras, making times, the missing Christmas date, the preview, the guarantee and returns, the email and phone number, the offers. Checked 11 November 2026.
- My Story Tale’s product and cart data: the price of every book, and a shipping quote for one and three hardcovers to Sydney NSW 2000. 11 November 2026.
- ABN Lookup, ABN 79 689 778 489: https://abr.business.gov.au/ABN/View?abn=79689778489. Personalised Story Group Pty Ltd, ABN active and GST registered from 6 August 2025, main business location NSW 2370, its trading names. Checked 11 November 2026.
- WHOIS for mystorytale.com: registered 25 July 2024. Checked 11 November 2026.
- Story Bug’s and Hooray Heroes’ contact-information pages and Hooray Heroes’ terms of service name Personalized Story Group, Inc. Checked 11 November 2026.
- My Story Tale’s claim of 100,000 orders in its first eight months: its LinkedIn post, about January 2026.
- My Story Tale on Trustpilot, https://www.trustpilot.com/review/mystorytale.com: 4.9 from 7,019 reviews and the count at each star, read 11 November 2026, 04:01 AEDT. Every 1 to 3 star review, 89, and the 250 most recent 4 and 5 star reviews, pulled and read 11 November 2026. Reviews quoted: https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/6aa2b5c080f188ace0b947c0 (10 September 2026), https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/6ae2c2011a65cd414a467191 (29 October 2026, and the preview reply quoted), https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/6a006340d58def3914967352 (10 May 2026), https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/6a292de6cfabfcea9e211348 (10 June 2026), https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/69cdc503103d9a3e87b356b6 (2 April 2026), https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/6acf1c7321e4326dede0bac4 (14 October 2026), https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/693f97955091f836c8145eb2 (15 December 2025), https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/6af0992f1fcf4be9feb985c5 (8 November 2026), https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/69974ce2d2b12b4fe1e52d19 (19 February 2026), https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/698c95909ed2f06b60fee170 (11 February 2026), https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/6ae04a3d42c1e41ad5ef0db3 (27 October 2026), https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/693c50838b392876aca7cf76 (12 December 2025), https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/695817bb1a74bf668c0dfd6a (2 January 2026, and My Story Tale’s reply), https://www.trustpilot.com/reviews/6a9501777edc5b9e6663213f (My Story Tale’s reply, 31 August 2026).
- ProductReview.com.au and BBB searches and a Google Business Profile lookup: no listing found. 11 November 2026.
- My Story Tale’s Facebook page, “My Story Tale Books | Princeton NJ”. Checked 5 November 2026.
- Reddit, searched across all subreddits, 11 November 2026.

Paperlake publishes this review and makes one of the two books in it. We kept to facts read on 11 November 2026, and suggest reading independent reviews too. How we compare brands: our methodology.

4.9 from 7,019 Trustpilot reviews